A single arm, open label pilot study of low dose regular opioids with low dose regular benzodiazepines for the relief of refractory breathlessness.
A single arm, open label pilot study of low dose regular opioids with low dose regular benzodiazepines for the palliative relief of breathlessness for people with refractory dyspnoea.
Flinders University
10 participants
Aug 20, 2010
Interventional
Conditions
Summary
Breathlessness at rest or on minimal exertion (speaking, bathing, dressing) continues to be a major clinical problem for many people with advanced progressive illnesses such as cancer, end-stage cardiac failure or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease even when they are receiving the best treatment for that underlying disease. Although there are some interventions that may offer benefit (oxygen therapy (when oxygen levels in the blood are low), sustained release low dose morphine) for this refractory breathlessness, other therapeutic options need to be explored. Benzodiazepines are widely used as sedatives to help with sleep, to reduce anxiety and to decrease the risk of seizures in people who have, or are at risk of epilepsy. These medications are also widely used around the world to treat breathlessness, however there have been no adequately powered studies that have explored net symptomatic benefit (symptom relief, side effects, maintenance of any benefit) for refractory breathlessness. Each benzodiazepine has slightly different properties in the level of sedation, ability to reduce anxiety and duration of effect. Two key questions need to be answered in order to establish the place of benzodiazepines in the management of refractory background dyspnoea: is there a net symptomatic benefit from benzodiazepines and, if so, is that benefit maintained over time? The latter question is important given the rapid tolerance to benzodiazepines when used as sedatives. Given the ability to dose once daily, the well defined pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamics (including in children) and the range of formulations/routes of administration available, clonazepam has been chosen for this study. The proposed dose is unlikely to cause significant sedation and is at the lower end of the dosing range for its major long term clinical use in epilepsy. Aim: The primary aim of this pilot study is to refine protocol design including recruitment and retention to the study, establish levels of symptomatic response and variance in that response for power calculations for a definitive trial, and establish whether that benefit is maintained at two weeks.
Eligibility
Inclusion Criteria7
- Adults (age>18)
- Refractory dyspnoea where the underlying cause of the dyspnoea has been maximally treated.
- A medical specialist must document that all identified reversible causes of the dyspnoea are being optimally managed
- Breathlessness of a level 3 or higher on Modified Medical Research COuncil (MRC) dyspnoea scale
- On stable medications over the prior week except “as needed” medications
- Prognosis of at least 2 months in the opinion of the treating clinician
- English-speaking and able to read questionnaires
Exclusion Criteria11
- Allergic to clonazepam or to other benzodiazepines
- Severe liver disease, key results greater than three times the upper limit of normal for the local laboratory
- On regular opioid medications above the dose in the study (10 mg)
- Anemia requiring transfusion
- Confusion with a Folstein Mini-mental Status Exam <24/30.
- Severely restricted performance status with Australian Modified Karnofsky Scale score of <50 at baseline
- Uncontrolled nausea, vomiting and/or gastrointestinal obstruction.
- Renal dysfunction with creatinine clearance calculated as less than 25 mls / minute.
- Evidence of respiratory depression with resting respiratory rate less than 8 breaths per minute or a history of opioid induced respiratory depression.
- Active respiratory or cardiac event in the previous week, not including upper respiratory tract infections.
- Unable to give informed consent or complete diary entries.
Interested in this trial?
Get notified about updates and connect with the research team.
Interventions
All participants will take one dose of regular low dose oral sustained release morphine (10 mg) every morning and one dose of oral clonazepam (0.5 mg) every evening of each day of the intervention period. A total of four doses of oral clonazepam and five doses of low dose oral sustained release morphine will be administered to all participants. This is a four day (96 hour) study. Participants will complete the study intervention in the morning of the 5th day when the exit assessments will be made. In order that participants may continue with ongoing treatment a 5th morphine dose is administered in the morning of the exit assessment.
Locations(3)
View Full Details on ANZCTR
For the most up-to-date information, visit the official listing.
ACTRN12610000589088