The Trial of Emergency Medicine Protocols In Simulation Sraining (TEMPIST) study
Effectiveness of the Handbook of Emergency Protocols on adherence to current resuscitation guidelines compared to no handbook among medical and nursing staff in a simulated environment: a block randomised controlled trial.
University Centre for Rural Health
120 participants
Oct 18, 2016
Interventional
Conditions
Summary
The primary purpose of the study is to investigate the feasibility of using the Handbook Emergency Protocols during simulated medical emergencies. It is expected that use of the handbook of emergency protocols will be at least be as effective as current models of care. It is anticipated that use of these protocols may lead to more accurate adherence to current resuscitation guidelines. In the TEMPIST study we will evaluate the standard list of emergency guidelines in current use in Australia. All of these guidelines have been reformatted into a step by step, easy to follow format, presented as a Handbook of Emergency Protocols. It is the presentation of this information that has been modified in order to produce a simple cognitive aid for medical staff. Experts from the aircraft industry and graphic designers have been consulted in an attempt to produce a handbook that is free of excessive information and visual distraction. Attention has been given to the colour and size of the text used and diagrams have been designed to be clear and well presented. Instructions are delivered in an easy to follow, step by step format designed to be read out loud during a resuscitation event. The TEMPIST trial will investigate the feasibility of using the Handbook Emergency Protocols during simulated medical emergencies. Objective: The aim of this study is to determine whether the use of the Handbook of Emergency Protocols leads to, or detracts from, the provision of correct care, in accordance with current Australian and New Zealand Resuscitation Committee guidelines. Method : A prospective block randomized controlled trial will be conducted. The research will be conducted in a high fidelity simulation laboratory. Groups of medical staff will be asked to manage four simulated emergency medicine scenarios.Groups will receive either the Checklist scenario or usual care. Each group will manage two scenarios with the emergency protocol handbook and two scenarios using only the wall charts and drug administration handbooks that are found in every Australian Emergency Department. Each group will perform each scenario only once, either with or without the emergency protocol handbook. The four scenarios are: 1. Paediatric seizure 2. Adult pulseless ventricular tachycardia 3. Newborn resuscitation. 4. Tricyclic antidepressant overdose. Each scenario will be recorded on video and the primary outcome measures will be a list of 15 tasks per scenario that are expected to be completed within the 15 minute time frame. At the end of all 4 clinical scenarios, participants will be asked to fill out a brief questionnaire to evaluate their subjective experience of using the emergency protocol handbook and to try and identify potential hurdles to its adoption. The patient will be a simulation manikin (Sim man 3G). The trial groups will be made up from doctors and nurses with a mixed level of emergency medical training.
Eligibility
Plain Language Summary
Simplified for easier understanding
This is a simplified summary. Always discuss eligibility with your doctor before enrolling in a clinical trial.
Interested in this trial?
Get notified about updates and connect with the research team.
Interventions
In the TEMPIST study we will evaluate the standard list of emergency guidelines in current use in Australia. The Handbook of Emergency Medicine Protocols has been designed as a cognitive aid for medical staff who have to manage medical emergencies that are both life threatening and time critical. Current protocols have been reformatted as simple, single step by step pathways, The content of the protocols has not been altered. Careful consideration has been given to the graphic design, text, diagrams and fonts used on each page, following consultation with experts from the aviation industry who design pilot manuals. Instructions are delivered in an easy to follow, step by step format designed to be read out loud during a resuscitation event. The TEMPIST trial will investigate the feasibility of using the Handbook Emergency Protocols during simulated medical emergencies. Objective: The aim of this study is to determine whether the use of the Handbook of Emergency Protocols leads to, or detracts from, the provision of correct care, in accordance with current Australian and New Zealand Resuscitation Committee guidelines. The research will be conducted in a high fidelity simulation laboratory. Study participants will be asked to manage four simulated emergency medicine scenarios. Groups of medical staff will be asked to manage four simulated emergency medicine scenarios. Groups will receive either the Checklist scenario or usual care. Each group will manage two scenarios with the emergency protocol handbook and two scenarios using only the wall charts and drug administration handbooks that are found in every Australian Emergency Department. Each group will perform each scenario only once, either with or without the emergency protocol handbook. The Groups will be randomly assigned, using a computer generated number table, to manage the emergency scenario, with or without, the Handbook of Emergency Protocols. Each group will be given a verbal prompt leading into the scenario and advised whether the protocol book will or will not be available. Each group will then be asked to manage the emergency scenario within the simulation laboratory. Each scenario will be conducted in the simulation laboratory with a set up designed to replicate a resuscitation bay in an Emergency Department. High fidelity manikins will be used and the room will contain standard patient monitoring and resuscitation equipment. The group being studied will be given a brief clinical prompt and then advised to proceed with the resuscitation. Initial observations (Pulse, BP, ECG rhythm, Oxygen saturation) will be exactly the same, each time the scenario is performed. A video recording will be made of the resuscitation effort. If a group fails to intervene in a timely manner, the simulated patient will be programmed to deteriorate clinically. Correct interventions will be reflected by improving clinical observations where relevant. Each scenario will be limited to a 15 minute duration. The four scenarios are: 1. Paediatric seizure 2. Adult pulseless ventricular tachycardia 3. Newborn resuscitation 4. Tricyclic antidepressant overdose. The patient will be a simulation manikin (Sim man 3G). The trial groups will be made up from doctors and nurses with a mixed level of emergency medical training. It is expected that use of the handbook will be at least as effective as current models of care. At the end of all 4 clinical scenarios, participants will be asked to fill out a questionnaire to evaluate their subjective experience of using the emergency protocol handbook and to try and identify potential hurdles to its adoption.
Locations(7)
View Full Details on ANZCTR
For the most up-to-date information, visit the official listing.
ACTRN12616001456448