RecruitingACTRN12620000887976

Does the use of the Canadian CT Head rule (CCHR) definition of minor head injury in a regional NSW emergency department safely lead to lower utilisation of computer tomography (CT) imaging in patients over 65 when compared to the NSW Closed Head Injury guidelines definition?


Sponsor

University of New South Wales

Enrollment

1,080 participants

Start Date

Jul 13, 2020

Study Type

Observational

Conditions

Summary

Mild head injury (MHI) in the elderly population is a very common presenting complaint to the emergency department. After assessment, the main decision health providers need to make is whether or not the patient requires a CT Brain to assess for significant intra-cranial injury such as intracranial haemorrhage. Current NSW Health Head Injury guidelines define a minor head injury as “a patient with an initial Glasgow Coma Score (GCS) of 14-15 on arrival at hospital following acute blunt head trauma with or without a definite history of loss of consciousness or post traumatic amnesia”. As a result of this broad definition, almost all patients in NSW who present to the emergency department after blunt head trauma undergo a CT scan. In comparison, the “Canadian CT Head Rule (CCHR)”, which is the most commonly used and validated clinical decision rule around head injury, defines MHI as a patient with a GCS of 13-15 and who has one of the following; sustains a period of loss of consciousness, post- traumatic amnesia or disorientation post head impact. Using this inclusion criteria, the CCHR definition and rule was shown to be 100% sensitive and 69% specific for the need for detecting need for neuro-surgical interventions post head injury. It was also 98% sensitive and 50% specific for detecting clinically significant brain injury. Our study will aim to assess whether the use of this more restrictive imaging strategy can safely reduce the number of CT Brains ordered post MHI in a regional NSW emergency department.


Eligibility

Sex: Both males and femalesMin Age: 65 Yearss

Plain Language Summary

Simplified for easier understanding

Head injuries are very common in older adults, and after a knock to the head, one of the key decisions doctors face is whether to order a CT scan to look for internal bleeding in the brain. Current NSW Health guidelines cast a wide net — meaning almost all older patients who attend emergency departments after a head injury receive a CT scan, even when the risk of serious injury is low. This leads to a large number of CT scans, which involve radiation exposure and significant costs. The Canadian CT Head Rule (CCHR) is an internationally validated decision-making tool that uses a narrower definition of "minor head injury" — requiring that the person actually had a period of loss of consciousness, memory loss, or confusion after the impact. This study is assessing whether applying the CCHR definition in a regional NSW emergency department can safely reduce the number of CT brain scans ordered in patients aged 65 and over, without missing any serious injuries. This is a retrospective review study — it looks back at existing patient records. If you are 65 or older and attended the emergency department after a head injury with a Glasgow Coma Scale score of 13-15, your de-identified records may be included in this review. There is no active enrolment or treatment involved.

This summary was AI-generated to explain the trial in plain language. It is not medical advice. Always discuss eligibility with your doctor before enrolling in a clinical trial.

Interested in this trial?

Get notified about updates and connect with the research team.

Interventions

The study will combine both a retrospective and prospective arm assessing patients over 65 who present to the Port Macquarie Base Hospital emergency department (PMBH ED) after a blunt head trauma.

The study will combine both a retrospective and prospective arm assessing patients over 65 who present to the Port Macquarie Base Hospital emergency department (PMBH ED) after a blunt head trauma. The retrospective arm will involve a chart review of patients who presented due to head trauma from January-Decemeber 2019 and received a computerised tomography (CT) scan. Each patient electronic medical record (EMR) will be retrospectively assessed for the following features: 1. The presence of Canadian CT Head Rule (CCHR) inclusion criteria: Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) of 13-15 with one of the following: witnessed loss of consciousness, definite amnesia or witnessed disorientation post blunt head trauma 2. The presence of CCHR exclusion criteria: anticoagulation, dementia, intoxication, bleeding disorder, penetrating skull injury, depressed skull fracture, acute focal neurological deficit that can’t be ascribed to an extracerebral cause, no history of trauma as the primary event eg. syncope, post-traumatic seizure, unstable vitals due to trauma or reassessment of the same head injury 3. CT results and patient outcome 4. Length time from ordering to reporting of imaging within 24 hours 5. Miscellaneous: antiplatelet medication It will then be determined whether the patient should have undergone a CT brain according to the CCHR definition of minor head injury (MHI). Within the prospective arm of the study, all patients over 65 that present to PMBH ED from 13th July- 31st August 2020 post blunt head injury will be prospectively enrolled. Clinicians ordering a CT Brain in this population will be asked to answer questions via a pop up link in EMR that will auto-populate. This data will be cross-checked with the patients electronic medical record and additionally assessed for the above features. After the data is collected it will then be analysed to see if applying the more restrictive CCHR definition of minor head injury can safely decrease the utilisation of CT Brains in this population without missing a clinically significant brain injury. Clinically significant brain injury is defined according to the CCHR as any acute brain finding on CT which would normally require admission to hospital and neurological follow-up unless the patient is neurologically intact and has one of the following lesions: solitary contusion less than 5 mm in diameter; localised subarachnoid blood less than 1mm thick; smear subdural haematoma less than 4 mm thick; isolated pneumocephaly, or closed depressed skull fracture not through the inner table.


Locations(1)

Port Macquarie Base Hospital - Port Macquarie

NSW, Australia

View Full Details on ANZCTR

For the most up-to-date information, visit the official listing.

Visit

ACTRN12620000887976


Related Trials